New Stepparent? Build Relationship First, Discipline Second
If you are a new stepparent, it is very easy to feel pressure to “step up” and act like a full parent right away. But Dr. Patricia Papernow, in Surviving and Thriving in Stepfamily Relationships, gives very different advice. Her counsel is simple and wise: relationship first, discipline second.
I think that is exactly right.
In stepfamilies, love and trust usually do not appear overnight. A biological parent has years of attachment history with a child. A stepparent does not. That does not mean the stepparent cannot become deeply loved and respected. It means the relationship has to be built in a different way: patiently, gently, and over time.
Papernow’s main “do” and “don’t” are refreshingly clear.
What a new stepparent should do
- Let the parent remain the primary disciplinarian, especially early on. Papernow says, “Parents remain the disciplinarians.” In the early years, direct correction and consequences should usually come from the child’s own parent.
- Build connection before trying to correct behavior. Her summary is unforgettable: “Connection before correction!” and “Relationships before rules.” That is such a healthy goal for a new blended family.
- Support the parent rather than trying to replace the parent. Papernow says stepparents often do best as “sounding boards, not as saviors.” In other words, raise concerns privately with your spouse, not in front of the child.
- Choose low-conflict ways to be involved. Shared activities, encouragement, teaching, and simple presence can go a long way. A stepparent can become a trusted adult through consistency and warmth, not force.
- When the parent is absent, enforce existing house rules only. Papernow says stepparents should function more like “an adult babysitter, aunt, or uncle,” communicating the parent’s expectations. “Parents enforce the consequences, not stepparents.”
What a new stepparent should not do
- Do not rush into discipline. Papernow warns that pushing stepparents into that role too early is “a recipe for distress and disappointment all around.”
- Do not take over because “somebody’s got to do it.” She says this puts stepparents in “an unworkable position.”
- Do not use authoritarian discipline. Papernow says the “hostile and firm” style is “particularly toxic in stepparent-stepchild relationships.”
- Do not assume love or concern automatically gives you parental authority. Even if you care deeply, the child may not yet experience you as emotionally safe enough to receive correction well.
- Do not expect quick acceptance. Papernow says closeness between stepparent and stepchild is “usually not a given.” It takes patience, flexibility, and time.
That last point matters so much. A lot of pain in stepfamilies comes from unrealistic expectations. People think, “We live together now, so this child should respond to me like a parent.” But that is usually not how human relationships work.
Trust has to be earned.
In my opinion, this advice is not about lowering the importance of stepparents. It is about giving them a role they can actually succeed in. The new stepparent often does best by becoming a calm, kind, trustworthy adult in the child’s life rather than the main enforcer.
That does not mean boundaries disappear. Children still need structure. But early on, the biological parent is usually in the best position to handle discipline while the stepparent focuses on building warmth, credibility, and emotional safety.
Papernow’s bottom line is that discipline may expand later, but usually after trust has developed, often over “at least a couple of years.” That is a helpful reminder for blended families who feel discouraged. If closeness feels slow, that does not mean you are failing. It may mean you are normal.
Go slower. Build trust. Choose relationship first.
3 Common Problems and Solutions
Problem 1. Insider / Outsider Binds
Papernow says stepfamily structure puts parents and stepparents on opposite sides of a divide: when the family is together, children and their biological parent are the “insiders,” and the stepparent is the “outsider.” To keep the stepparent from feeling discouraged or left out, the fix is not forced blending, but empathy toward the stepparent, one-to-one time, and “compartmentalizing” (giving each relationship its own space, as opposed to being all together all the time). This counters some advice given, but I’ve found it worked.
Problem 2. Parents Showing Kids a “Unified Front” and Public Affection
According to Papernow, one common mistake in stepfamilies is assuming the new couple should always show a “united front.” In stepfamilies, adults should cooperate, but not by erasing the parent-child bond. In other words, the adults should work together without acting as though the new couple relationship always comes first or the child’s connection to their biological parent no longer needs to be honored and protected. She also says adult physical affection should be mostly private because it can heighten children’s feelings of loss and loyalty binds.
Problem 3. Protect Alone Time with the Bio Parent
Papernow says parent-child alone time is “pivotal” for children’s wellbeing and stepfamily success. It preserves the child’s secure bond with the biological parent and reduces the sense of being replaced by the stepparent.
Source: Patricia Papernow, Surviving and Thriving in Stepfamily Relationships. Patricia Papernow, EdD, is a psychologist, stepfamily educator, and longtime expert on blended family relationships.
Real Case Study: Frustration with Adult Step-Child
Question: What Should I Do? I have a 40-year-old stepdaughter who is spunky, confident, and vivacious. She has that East Coast sense of humor that feels cutting and mocking. She has a good heart, but she hogs the spotlight. A month ago, I was so frustrated, I just let my anger out on her, and mentioned something about her wearing those “god-awful red pants.” That must have hurt her. I feel bad about it. Should I apologize? How should I deal with this relationship in the future?
Answer: Using Papernow’s book, I’d say yes: apologize for the “red pants” comment, briefly and without defending it. You snapped; own that cleanly. Then stop trying to correct your stepdaughter directly. Papernow’s view is that stepfamilies often lock people into insider/outsider roles: parent and child are insiders, stepparent is often the outsider. That can leave the stepparent worn down and reactive, while the stepchild may use old family power without realizing the impact. Papernow recommends holding empathy for both sides. You were hurt and frustrated; she also has a style that steamrolls the room. Both can be true.
A simple apology might be: “I’m sorry for what I said about your pants. That was mean and unfair.” Going forward, work through your spouse, not against your stepdaughter. Ask your partner to help manage the family space so others can speak. Aim for civility, not a big emotional reckoning. Less direct correction, less forced togetherness, and more structure will probably help most.
Related reading
:
:
Buy PDF